This debate1 is not really about guns, crime or even corruption, but two different world-views.
One is where people believe that responsibility for your life lies with someone else, and that other people know better about how you should live. That is a world-view of dependence and authoritarianism.
The other is one of self-reliance—that responsibility for your life and your family begins with yourself.
Petals 2 demands that government should be 100% effective in defending him and his family. But who is the government but a group of people? In other words, Petals insists that someone else takes care of his family. He demands that others risk their lives for him. So sure is he of these convictions that he advocates that everyone else should be forced to do the same. These are heavy demands to make of strangers!
Expecting the government to guarantee us a safe and happy life is a fool's dream. There have always been bad people who want to harm innocents. Sometimes these people are labeled criminals or sociopaths. Oftentimes in history, they have been from the government itself.
Still, there are those out there who say, "Leave it to the government. They will take care of us!" But did the government prevent the Maguindanao massacre? More recently, were the police able to protect those poor tourists during the Mendoza bus hijack?
The truth is that we alone have the primary responsibility to take care of ourselves and our families. The government can be there to provide support, but safeguarding an individual's life is not the government's job.
Walang armas ang demokrasya ("democracy doesn't have weapons"), says Petals. Such platitudes may sound righteous but are completely meaningless. Tell that to the victims in the 'Democratic' Republic of Congo, where world's second-largest peacekeeping force were unable to prevent 7,000 rapes and 1,433 civilian killings in 2009. (Source: Genocide Intervention Network)
Freedom is protected by strength and arms. Eloquent speeches and the ability to vote are worth nothing if someone has a gun to your head. The only thing that keeps that gun away is another gun.
1. This post is an edited version of my contribution to a firearms discussion on President Noynoy Aquino's Facebook page.
2. 'Petals' is the nickname that people have given to one of the vocal gun control advocates on the discussion. I'd say that you can use him as a stand-in for progressives in general.